LessonsThe First Figure: Conditions of Validity and Four Productive MoodsQuiz

Productive example: Every cat is an animal. Every animal has a body. So every cat has a body. The minor premise places cats within animals.

Unproductive example: No cat is a bird. Every bird is an animal. We cannot infer that no cat is an animal: a cat can be an animal without being a bird.

A negative minor separates the minor term from the middle term. Thus the major premise's judgment about the middle does not transfer to the minor in the way required for first-figure inference.

Opening interactive controls...

Why the minor premise must be affirmative

The First Figure: Conditions of Validity and Four Productive Moods

Productive example: Every cat is an animal. Every animal has a body. So every cat has a body. The minor premise places cats within animals.

Unproductive example: No cat is a bird. Every bird is an animal. We cannot infer that no cat is an animal: a cat can be an animal without being a bird.

A negative minor separates the minor term from the middle term. Thus the major premise's judgment about the middle does not transfer to the minor in the way required for first-figure inference.