LessonsThe Five Predicables: Differentia, Property, Common Accident, Essential and Accidental AttributesQuiz

وليس كل مقسم للعالي مقسما للسافل.
Not every feature that divides a higher genus divides each of its lower species.

'Sentient' can divide a wider class of growing bodies into animals and non-animals. It does not then divide animals into sentient and non-sentient animals: in this classical account all animals are sentient.

Inheritance of a constitutive feature down a hierarchy does not imply repeated subdivision by that same feature at every subordinate level.

Opening interactive controls...

Why the corresponding converse fails

The Five Predicables: Differentia, Property, Common Accident, Essential and Accidental Attributes

وليس كل مقسم للعالي مقسما للسافل.
Not every feature that divides a higher genus divides each of its lower species.

'Sentient' can divide a wider class of growing bodies into animals and non-animals. It does not then divide animals into sentient and non-sentient animals: in this classical account all animals are sentient.

Inheritance of a constitutive feature down a hierarchy does not imply repeated subdivision by that same feature at every subordinate level.