LessonsThe Third Figure: Conditions and Six Productive MoodsQuiz

An affirmative minor tells us that the middle has instances falling under the minor term. The major can then describe these same middle-term instances with respect to the major predicate.

A negative minor excludes the minor predicate from the middle and does not locate any minor-term instances to which the major can be applied.

Example:
No horse is a bird.
All horses are animals.

Neither “Some birds are animals” nor “Some birds are not animals” follows from these premises. They describe horses, not the required bird instances.

Opening interactive controls...

Why the minor premise must affirm

The Third Figure: Conditions and Six Productive Moods

An affirmative minor tells us that the middle has instances falling under the minor term. The major can then describe these same middle-term instances with respect to the major predicate.

A negative minor excludes the minor predicate from the middle and does not locate any minor-term instances to which the major can be applied.

Example:
No horse is a bird.
All horses are animals.

Neither “Some birds are animals” nor “Some birds are not animals” follows from these premises. They describe horses, not the required bird instances.