LessonsQur’anic Argumentation: Christian Doctrines, the Trinity, Crucifixion and the ParacleteQuiz

عَقِيدَةُ التَّثْلِيثِ وَالرَّدُّ عَلَيْهَا
The doctrine of the Trinity and its refutation.

The disputation introduces three aqanim (hypostases): Father, Son and Holy Spirit. In the source’s representation, divine reality is spoken of through three distinct designations, and an asserted connection or union among these designations becomes a point of criticism.

Two questions must be kept apart. Do multiple attributes or relations imply multiple deities? And does attributing a divine property or relation to a created being make that being divine? The first concerns divine unity; the second concerns the distinction between Creator and creation.

The account belongs to a historical Muslim-Christian debate. Different Christian theological traditions formulate hypostatic language differently; the argument here answers the particular description presented in this text.

Opening interactive controls...

The three hypostases in the source’s account

Qur’anic Argumentation: Christian Doctrines, the Trinity, Crucifixion and the Paraclete

عَقِيدَةُ التَّثْلِيثِ وَالرَّدُّ عَلَيْهَا
The doctrine of the Trinity and its refutation.

The disputation introduces three aqanim (hypostases): Father, Son and Holy Spirit. In the source’s representation, divine reality is spoken of through three distinct designations, and an asserted connection or union among these designations becomes a point of criticism.

Two questions must be kept apart. Do multiple attributes or relations imply multiple deities? And does attributing a divine property or relation to a created being make that being divine? The first concerns divine unity; the second concerns the distinction between Creator and creation.

The account belongs to a historical Muslim-Christian debate. Different Christian theological traditions formulate hypostatic language differently; the argument here answers the particular description presented in this text.