LessonsQur’anic Argumentation: Debates with Jewish Interlocutors and Principles of ReformQuiz

Tahrif (alteration) changes existing wording or shifts the sense away from its intended meaning. It may involve the wording itself or its interpretation.

Kitman (concealment) withholds a relevant command or testimony; the words may remain unchanged but are hidden when they matter. Iftira’ (fabrication) presents an unsupported assertion as divinely authorized.

For example, changing the wording of a rule, giving it a forced interpretation, deliberately not disclosing it, and inventing a rule in God’s name are four analytically distinct acts. Recognizing these distinctions prevents the later cases from becoming an undifferentiated accusation.

Opening interactive controls...

Alteration, concealment and fabrication are different

Qur’anic Argumentation: Debates with Jewish Interlocutors and Principles of Reform

Tahrif (alteration) changes existing wording or shifts the sense away from its intended meaning. It may involve the wording itself or its interpretation.

Kitman (concealment) withholds a relevant command or testimony; the words may remain unchanged but are hidden when they matter. Iftira’ (fabrication) presents an unsupported assertion as divinely authorized.

For example, changing the wording of a rule, giving it a forced interpretation, deliberately not disclosing it, and inventing a rule in God’s name are four analytically distinct acts. Recognizing these distinctions prevents the later cases from becoming an undifferentiated accusation.