LessonsAdvanced Applied Usul: Testing Evidence and Inference (Supplementary)Quiz

Suppose 200 local residents agree on a question, but it is unknown whether they are jurists qualified for independent legal reasoning. Numbers alone do not establish technical ijma. The book's definition requires the agreement of the qualified mujtahids of an era.

An ijma claim therefore requires identifying the competent jurists, showing how their agreement is established, and specifying the relevant category. Public popularity, institutional agreement, and technical consensus are not synonyms.

Opening interactive controls...

Ijma: agreement by whom and when?

Advanced Applied Usul: Testing Evidence and Inference (Supplementary)

Suppose 200 local residents agree on a question, but it is unknown whether they are jurists qualified for independent legal reasoning. Numbers alone do not establish technical ijma. The book's definition requires the agreement of the qualified mujtahids of an era.

An ijma claim therefore requires identifying the competent jurists, showing how their agreement is established, and specifying the relevant category. Public popularity, institutional agreement, and technical consensus are not synonyms.