The certainty of a Qur'anic text's transmission and the determination of its meaning are distinct matters. The wording containing “quru'” is established, yet jurists have disputed whether this word refers to menstruation or periods of purity.
A learner who argues that a certain text must have one undisputed interpretation confuses transmission with indication. The sound method is to establish the text first, then evaluate the competing interpretive arguments concerning a shared expression.
Opening interactive controls...
Applied Usul al-Fiqh: Guided Case Studies (Supplementary)
The certainty of a Qur'anic text's transmission and the determination of its meaning are distinct matters. The wording containing “quru'” is established, yet jurists have disputed whether this word refers to menstruation or periods of purity.
A learner who argues that a certain text must have one undisputed interpretation confuses transmission with indication. The sound method is to establish the text first, then evaluate the competing interpretive arguments concerning a shared expression.