LessonsAuthority of Qiyas and Five Conditions for Sound AnalogyQuiz

An analogy must support only the conclusion actually justified by its evidence. The debt comparison does not establish that every act of worship may be performed by anyone for anyone else without conditions.

Pilgrimage has distinct requirements concerning capability, impediment and representation. The legal result extends only to the extent that the relevant common cause is established.

If a proposed extension contradicts an applicable textual provision, the forthcoming condition against opposing the text prevents that extension.

Opening interactive controls...

Limits of the pilgrimage analogy

Authority of Qiyas and Five Conditions for Sound Analogy

An analogy must support only the conclusion actually justified by its evidence. The debt comparison does not establish that every act of worship may be performed by anyone for anyone else without conditions.

Pilgrimage has distinct requirements concerning capability, impediment and representation. The legal result extends only to the extent that the relevant common cause is established.

If a proposed extension contradicts an applicable textual provision, the forthcoming condition against opposing the text prevents that extension.