LessonsAuthority of Qiyas and Five Conditions for Sound AnalogyQuiz

شروط صحة القياس خمسة
Five conditions govern the validity of qiyas.

ConditionRequired principle1Do not oppose an applicable text2Do not alter the textual ruling through extension3Extend only a ruling with an intelligible legal rationale4Base the effective cause on law, not language alone5Do not analogize a new case whose own ruling is already textual

The conditions do different work. The first two protect textual authority; the third and fourth test the legal cause; the fifth identifies where analogy has a legitimate place. Failure of one can invalidate the proposed analogy.

Opening interactive controls...

Five conditions of valid qiyas

Authority of Qiyas and Five Conditions for Sound Analogy

شروط صحة القياس خمسة
Five conditions govern the validity of qiyas.

ConditionRequired principle1Do not oppose an applicable text2Do not alter the textual ruling through extension3Extend only a ruling with an intelligible legal rationale4Base the effective cause on law, not language alone5Do not analogize a new case whose own ruling is already textual

The conditions do different work. The first two protect textual authority; the third and fourth test the legal cause; the fifth identifies where analogy has a legitimate place. Failure of one can invalidate the proposed analogy.