LessonsLiteral and Figurative Meanings: Principles and Legal ApplicationsQuiz

A transfer to figurative meaning does not mean that every remotely associated thing may be inserted into the oath. The intended substitute must have a recognized relation to the word and to the action described.

Tree: the edible fruit is the normal candidate.
Pot: the food prepared in or taken from it is what the statement concerns.

If literal consumption is realistically possible in a different context, one must reconsider the claim of impossibility and the role of convention. The classification depends on the actual statement and usage, not on a desire for the most convenient interpretation.

Opening interactive controls...

Limits of the tree and pot example

Literal and Figurative Meanings: Principles and Legal Applications

A transfer to figurative meaning does not mean that every remotely associated thing may be inserted into the oath. The intended substitute must have a recognized relation to the word and to the action described.

Tree: the edible fruit is the normal candidate.
Pot: the food prepared in or taken from it is what the statement concerns.

If literal consumption is realistically possible in a different context, one must reconsider the claim of impossibility and the role of convention. The classification depends on the actual statement and usage, not on a desire for the most convenient interpretation.