LessonsProhibition: Intrinsic Wrongfulness, External Defects, and Legal EffectsQuiz

البيع الفاسد يفيد الملك عند القبض باعتبار أنه بيع ويجب نقضه باعتبار كونه حراماً لغيره
In a defective sale, ownership can arise upon possession because the transaction retains the basic form of a sale; it must be rescinded because of the prohibited attached defect.

Consider a sale stipulating an unlawful extra benefit. Its contractual basis remains identifiable, yet the stipulation makes it defective. Recognition of a consequence of possession does not legalize the condition.

Two conclusions coexist: an ownership effect may arise, and the transaction may have to be undone or corrected.

Opening interactive controls...

Effects of possession under a defective sale

Prohibition: Intrinsic Wrongfulness, External Defects, and Legal Effects

البيع الفاسد يفيد الملك عند القبض باعتبار أنه بيع ويجب نقضه باعتبار كونه حراماً لغيره
In a defective sale, ownership can arise upon possession because the transaction retains the basic form of a sale; it must be rescinded because of the prohibited attached defect.

Consider a sale stipulating an unlawful extra benefit. Its contractual basis remains identifiable, yet the stipulation makes it defective. Recognition of a consequence of possession does not legalize the condition.

Two conclusions coexist: an ownership effect may arise, and the transaction may have to be undone or corrected.