LessonsProhibition: Intrinsic Wrongfulness, External Defects, and Legal EffectsQuiz

والاصطياد بقوس مغصوبة، والذبح بسكين مغصوبة
Hunting with a usurped bow and slaughtering with a usurped knife similarly distinguish unlawful use of an implement from the legal consequence of the main act.

Unlawful use: employing another person’s property without permission is prohibited.
Effect of hunting or slaughter: those acts have their own validity conditions, not all of which disappear merely because the implement was taken unlawfully.

Other requirements for lawful slaughter still apply. Ownership of the implement alone never settles the complete ruling on every hunt or slaughter.

Opening interactive controls...

Hunting and slaughter with usurped implements

Prohibition: Intrinsic Wrongfulness, External Defects, and Legal Effects

والاصطياد بقوس مغصوبة، والذبح بسكين مغصوبة
Hunting with a usurped bow and slaughtering with a usurped knife similarly distinguish unlawful use of an implement from the legal consequence of the main act.

Unlawful use: employing another person’s property without permission is prohibited.
Effect of hunting or slaughter: those acts have their own validity conditions, not all of which disappear merely because the implement was taken unlawfully.

Other requirements for lawful slaughter still apply. Ownership of the implement alone never settles the complete ruling on every hunt or slaughter.