LessonsThe Book of Allah as a Primary SourceQuiz

Now apply the same distinction in the other direction:

• A ruling may remain operative even when no wording about it is present in the Mushaf as a Quranic verse.
• The author illustrates this with the operative legal punishment for zina by a married person, while stating that wording about it is not transmitted in the Mushaf as a Quranic verse.
• The lesson's limited conclusion is: an operative ruling does not by itself make reported wording Quranic. Its proof may belong to another source.

This is a source-classification example only. This level does not study the offence, evidence, conditions or punishment.

Opening interactive controls...

Source Contrast: An Operative Ruling Is a Different Question

The Book of Allah as a Primary Source

Now apply the same distinction in the other direction:

• A ruling may remain operative even when no wording about it is present in the Mushaf as a Quranic verse.
• The author illustrates this with the operative legal punishment for zina by a married person, while stating that wording about it is not transmitted in the Mushaf as a Quranic verse.
• The lesson's limited conclusion is: an operative ruling does not by itself make reported wording Quranic. Its proof may belong to another source.

This is a source-classification example only. This level does not study the offence, evidence, conditions or punishment.