عملنا بهما على وجه لا يتغير به حكم الكتاب
Both proofs are applied in a way that does not change the character of the Qurʾānic rule.
The general Qurʾānic obligation establishes basic recitation. The report about al-Fātiḥah is not discarded; it establishes a distinct special requirement.
This is one form of reconciling proofs: giving both texts a legal role instead of treating one as cancelling the other altogether. The schools still disagree over the sound interpretation and its consequences.
Opening interactive controls...
The Scope of General Expressions, Specification and Solitary Reports
عملنا بهما على وجه لا يتغير به حكم الكتاب
Both proofs are applied in a way that does not change the character of the Qurʾānic rule.
The general Qurʾānic obligation establishes basic recitation. The report about al-Fātiḥah is not discarded; it establishes a distinct special requirement.
This is one form of reconciling proofs: giving both texts a legal role instead of treating one as cancelling the other altogether. The schools still disagree over the sound interpretation and its consequences.