LessonsAccidents: Definition, Categories and the Beginning of the Origination ArgumentQuiz

The four akwān are distinguished by two questions.

Relation of two substances: If a third cannot intervene, it is conjunction; if a third could intervene, it is separation.
Successive states of one substance: If the earlier place differs, it is motion; if it is the same, it is rest.

The first pair is about a relation between two subjects; the second about successive states of one subject. An assertion of motion is therefore not analyzed in the same way as an assertion of separation.

Opening interactive controls...

Comparing the four akwān

Accidents: Definition, Categories and the Beginning of the Origination Argument

The four akwān are distinguished by two questions.

Relation of two substances: If a third cannot intervene, it is conjunction; if a third could intervene, it is separation.
Successive states of one substance: If the earlier place differs, it is motion; if it is the same, it is rest.

The first pair is about a relation between two subjects; the second about successive states of one subject. An assertion of motion is therefore not analyzed in the same way as an assertion of separation.