LessonsCreed Casebook: Claims, Principles and Sound JudgmentsQuiz

Scenario: A patient reasons that because his outcome is decreed, seeking treatment and praying are pointless.

Governing principle: Decree does not negate seeking permissible means and supplicating; a person makes appropriate efforts while recognizing Allah as the ultimate source of efficacy.

Sound application: Seeking treatment, taking precautions and praying for recovery are compatible with responsibility.

Limit of the conclusion: This principle does not guarantee that any particular treatment will succeed.

Opening interactive controls...

Decree, lawful means and supplication

Creed Casebook: Claims, Principles and Sound Judgments

Scenario: A patient reasons that because his outcome is decreed, seeking treatment and praying are pointless.

Governing principle: Decree does not negate seeking permissible means and supplicating; a person makes appropriate efforts while recognizing Allah as the ultimate source of efficacy.

Sound application: Seeking treatment, taking precautions and praying for recovery are compatible with responsibility.

Limit of the conclusion: This principle does not guarantee that any particular treatment will succeed.