From Wa lā yakūnu illā mā yurīd to Bāʿithun bilā mashaqqah: limits of understanding, divine attributes, creating and providing, and concealed life in the grave Read the bilingual lesson for Divine Will, Self-Sufficiency, Life, and Resurrection and test your understanding with a focused quiz.
Lesson
1. Nothing occurs apart from Allah’s will
وَلَا يَكُونُ إِلَّا مَا يُرِيدُ.
Nothing takes place except what Allah wills.
No created thing possesses an independent power capable of bringing about an event in opposition to the divine will. Everything that occurs is subject to that will.
Both Allah’s willing of an event and its occurrence at its appointed time are encompassed by this statement.
2. Divine will and “Be, and it is”
إِنَّمَا أَمْرُهُ إِذَا أَرَادَ شَيْئًا أَنْ يَقُولَ لَهُ كُنْ فَيَكُونُ. (Yā Sīn 36:82)
When He intends something, His command is only to say to it, “Be,” and it comes to be.
Kun (“Be”) expresses the effectiveness of Allah’s will and command: what He intends occurs according to that command.
The command also includes the appointed time and period in which the intended event is to occur.
3. The time of fulfilment within the command
When Allah wills an event, the command “Kun” includes the period designated for that event to be manifested. The expression does not require every intended occurrence to become outwardly manifest in the same instant.
An event may become apparent immediately or after a specified period; in either case, it takes place by Allah’s will.
The essential distinction is that both the timing and the result remain subject to divine will.
4. Two illustrations of an appointed time
The birth of a child: When Allah wills to grant a child, the purport of “Kun” may include the child’s birth after the appointed period, such as nine months.
The coming of death: When Allah wills the death of a person, that death comes at the time He has determined.
In both illustrations there is no conflict between the divine command and the appointed interval. The time itself is included in that command.
5. Imagination and understanding cannot encompass Him
لَا تَبْلُغُهُ الْأَوْهَامُ وَلَا تُدْرِكُهُ الْأَفْهَامُ.
Imaginations do not reach His reality, nor do understandings encompass Him.
Awhām is the plural of wahm; afhām is the plural of fahm.
The statement sets the limits of both forms of human thought: unsound thought cannot reach knowledge of Allah’s reality, and even sound understanding cannot fully encompass the divine essence.
6. The distinction between awhām and afhām
Wahm denotes faulty thinking. It cannot provide a sound approach to Allah’s reality.
Fahm denotes sound understanding. Through it, a person comes to know of Allah, but this knowledge does not amount to comprehensive grasp of the divine essence.
Faulty thought failing to reach the truth and sound understanding remaining limited are distinct matters. The two negations address them differently.
7. Knowledge is not complete comprehension
Maʿrifah (knowledge) here means coming to know Allah through sound reflection. Iḥāṭah (comprehension) would mean encompassing the entire reality of the divine essence within human understanding.
Sound reflection can yield knowledge, but total comprehension of Allah’s essence lies beyond the power of human understanding.
It therefore does not follow that, because complete comprehension is impossible, knowledge of Allah is impossible.
8. Allah does not resemble human beings
وَلَا يُشْبِهُ الْأَنَامَ.
He does not resemble human beings.
Human seeing, hearing, speaking, and bodily existence are connected with physical organs and means. These created dependencies do not apply to Allah.
Affirming divine attributes is not the same as attributing resemblance to creatures. Allah possesses attributes without the needs of created beings.
9. Human perception depends on organs
Seeing: A human being relies on eyes to see.
Speaking: A human being relies on a tongue to speak.
Hearing: A human being relies on ears to hear.
Existing: Human existence is related to a body and its organs.
These dependencies belong to created beings. They must not be projected onto Allah’s essence.
10. Divine attributes do not depend on created organs
Allah sees without needing eyes.
Allah hears without needing ears.
Allah exists without needing a body or limbs.
Thus, the bodily dependencies of creatures are denied of Allah while the affirmation of His attributes remains intact.
11. The terms yad, wajh, ʿayn, and sāq
The Qur’an uses expressions concerning Allah such as yad, wajh, ʿayn, sāq, and others.
These expressions are not to be understood as the hands, face, eyes, or bodily organs of creatures. They concern Allah’s attributes.
Knowledge of the meaning and reality of these attributes belongs to Allah. His essence is free from created organs and dependence upon them.
12. Allah lives and does not die
حَيٌّ لَا يَمُوتُ، قَيُّومٌ لَا يَنَامُ.
He is Living and does not die; He is the Sustainer who upholds the order of existence, and He does not sleep.
Ḥayy is accompanied by lā yamūt: no death ever overtakes Allah’s life.
Qayyūm is accompanied by lā yanām: sleep is also negated of the One who sustains all things.
13. Why “does not die” follows Ḥayy
Ḥayy means living, while lā yamūt makes explicit that death can never affect Allah’s life.
A created being may be alive and later die, but Allah’s life is not of this kind.
Allah has always been living and will always live; His life is free of death.
14. Why “does not sleep” follows Qayyūm
Qayyūm means the One who upholds and sustains. The accompanying lā yanām expressly negates sleep.
A sleeping person remains alive, but during sleep cannot attend to oneself or to others as one does while awake.
Allah sustains everything. Freedom from sleep accompanies the complete sustaining power described here.
15. Allah creates without any need
خَالِقٌ بِلَا حَاجَةٍ، رَازِقٌ بِلَا مُؤْنَةٍ.
He creates without need and provides sustenance without toil.
Khāliqun bilā ḥājah means that Allah does not create to satisfy any need of His own.
The created being needs to be brought into existence; Allah has no need of that creature. He is al-Ṣamad, entirely free of dependence.
16. Al-Ṣamad: needed by all, dependent on none
لَا يَحْتَاجُ إِلَى أَحَدٍ وَيَحْتَاجُ إِلَيْهِ كُلُّ أَحَدٍ.
He needs no one, while everyone needs Him.
This explanation of al-Ṣamad establishes two points:
1. Allah needs no created being.
2. Every created being depends upon Allah.
Dependence upon another contradicts complete self-sufficiency. Creation must therefore not be treated as the outcome of a need on Allah’s part.
17. Providing sustenance entails no toil for Allah
Rāziqun bilā muʾnah means that Allah grants sustenance without bearing effort, toil, or hardship in granting it.
The condition of the Provider differs from that of the recipient seeking provision: Allah provides without toil, while creatures may face substantial work in obtaining their livelihood.
The creatures’ effort does not imply any need or exertion on Allah’s part.
18. Hardship in created human life
لَقَدْ خَلَقْنَا الْإِنْسَانَ فِي كَبَدٍ. (Al-Balad 90:4)
We have indeed created the human being amid hardship.
Kabad means hardship. Human beings encounter effort and difficulty at different stages of birth, life, and earning sustenance.
Allah, by contrast, neither needs creation for His own sake nor experiences toil in providing for it.
19. Neither need in creating nor toil in providing
Khāliqun bilā ḥājah — Creation does not fulfil any need of Allah.
Rāziqun bilā muʾnah — Providing sustenance does not require effort from Allah.
Creatures depend upon Allah and may endure hardship to obtain provision, but Allah is both self-sufficient and free from toil.
The two expressions together clarify His perfection in creating and providing.
20. Allah causes death without fear
مُمِيتٌ بِلَا مَخَافَةٍ، بَاعِثٌ بِلَا مَشَقَّةٍ.
He causes death without fear and raises the dead (on the Day of Resurrection) without hardship.
Mumītun bilā makhāfah means that, when Allah causes someone to die, He has no fear of injury or retaliation from that person or the person’s relatives.
Fear can indicate inability, while Allah is absolutely powerful and free from inability.
21. No fear of retaliation when causing death
When a person dies, Allah is not concerned that the person who dies could harm Him or that relatives might retaliate.
Such apprehension would indicate a limitation of power, whereas Allah’s power is free of every deficiency.
The words bilā makhāfah thus affirm His complete authority in causing death and His freedom from inability.
22. Raising the dead entails no difficulty
Bāʿithun bilā mashaqqah means that Allah will raise created beings on the Day of Resurrection without experiencing hardship in doing so.
إِنَّمَا أَمْرُهُ إِذَا أَرَادَ شَيْئًا أَنْ يَقُولَ لَهُ كُنْ فَيَكُونُ. (Yā Sīn 36:82)
When He wills something, His command is to say, “Be,” and it comes to be.
Every event is subject to His will; raising creation at the Resurrection is likewise no difficulty for Him.
23. Why bāʿith rather than muḥyī?
Bāʿithun bilā mashaqqah — The One who raises without hardship.
Muḥyin bilā mashaqqah — The One who gives life without hardship.
The choice of bāʿith draws attention to a particular distinction: after death, life exists in the grave; at the Gathering that hidden life becomes outwardly manifest as people are raised.
In this respect, baʿth (raising) expresses the event of Resurrection particularly clearly.
24. Life in the grave is concealed
Life in the grave is concealed life. It is not manifest to ordinary observation:
It is not seen with the eyes.
It is not felt by touch.
At the Gathering, after baʿth, that life becomes manifest and people assemble on the plain of Resurrection.
The fact that life in the grave is not outwardly perceptible does not amount to its denial.
25. Calling resurrection “revival” does not deny grave-life
The resurrection on the Last Day may also be described by the word iḥyāʾ (“giving life”). In this usage, it means that life which was concealed in the grave now becomes outwardly apparent.
In the grave: Life exists but is concealed from ordinary perception.
At the Gathering: That life becomes manifest as creation is raised.
Thus calling the Resurrection iḥyāʾ does not negate life in the grave.
Practice questions
Question 1
What is meant by “Wa lā yakūnu illā mā yurīd”?
- Only human intentions have effect
- Only what Allah wills comes to pass
- Events occur without any will
- Creatures can override Allah’s will
Question 2
Which word in Yā Sīn 36:82 expresses Allah’s command?
Question 3
How is “Kun” related to an event’s appointed period?
- The command cannot include a time period
- Only humans determine the time
- Everything must manifest at the same time
- The command may include the appointed time of occurrence
Question 4
What does the illustration of childbirth clarify?
- Birth always occurs immediately
- Birth is outside divine will
- A period such as nine months may fall within the command
- Childbirth is impossible
Question 5
Of which word is “awhām” the plural?
Question 6
What does “afhām” refer to?
- Sound understanding and reflection
- Physical organs alone
- The state of sleep
- The toil of earning provision
Question 7
What can sound understanding reach concerning Allah?
- It fully encompasses Allah’s essence
- It yields knowledge but not total comprehension
- It is merely faulty thought
- It necessarily denies Allah’s existence
Question 8
What is denied by “Wa lā yushbihu al-anām”?
- Allah’s existence
- All divine attributes
- Allah’s resemblance to creatures
- Allah’s provision
Question 9
What difference is given between human and divine hearing?
- Both depend on ears
- Humans need ears, Allah does not
- Humans cannot hear
- Allah does not hear
Question 10
Which statement is consistent with the treatment of yad, wajh, ʿayn, and sāq?
- They prove human-like bodily organs
- They have no relation to Allah
- They concern divine attributes, not creature-like limbs
- They concern sustenance alone
Question 11
What is taught by “Ḥayyun lā yamūt”?
- Allah lives and does not die
- Allah sleeps
- Creatures do not die
- Every human is self-sustaining
Question 12
Why is the negation of sleep joined to Qayyūm?
- Because sleep is a condition of provision
- Because a sleeping person cannot sustain affairs as while awake
- Because sleep equals life
- Because Qayyūm means a creature
Question 13
What is the central meaning of “Khāliqun bilā ḥājah”?
- Allah needs no created being
- Creatures need nothing
- Creation is impossible
- Every creature is a creator
Question 14
Which quality of al-Ṣamad is conveyed by the Arabic definition?
- He receives provision from all
- He needs none, while all need Him
- He depends on created assistance
- Every creature is independent
Question 15
What is negated in “Rāziqun bilā muʾnah”?
- The granting of provision
- The effort of creatures
- Toil for Allah in providing sustenance
- The existence of humans
Question 16
What does “kabad” mean in Al-Balad 90:4?
Question 17
How do the two statements differ?
- Both only negate sleep
- The first denies need in creating; the second denies toil in providing
- Both deny death
- Both describe human attributes
Question 18
What does “Mumītun bilā makhāfah” teach?
- Allah causes death without fear of retaliation
- Allah fears injury
- Every human can cause death
- Causing death is difficult for Allah
Question 19
What does “Bāʿithun bilā mashaqqah” mean?
- Raising creation will require great toil
- No one will be raised
- Allah raises people at the Resurrection without toil
- Creation will assist Allah in the Resurrection
Question 20
What point about grave-life explains the choice of “bāʿith”?
- All life in the grave is denied
- Life in the grave is concealed and becomes manifest at resurrection
- Grave-life is visibly the same as earthly life
- Baʿth only means sleep
Question 21
Which description of concealed life in the grave is correct?
- It is necessarily visible to the eye
- It is ordinarily felt by touch
- It exists despite not being perceived by ordinary senses
- It belongs only to living people in this world
Question 22
What does calling resurrection “iḥyāʾ” not imply?
- Denial of life in the grave
- Manifestation of life at resurrection
- The rising of creatures at the Gathering
- A distinction between concealed and manifest life
Question 23
What is the explanation of “Lā tablughuhu al-awhām”?
- Faulty thought cannot attain Allah’s reality
- Every conjecture is sound knowledge
- Allah resembles creatures
- Thought alone keeps humans alive
Question 24
What is denied by “Lā tudrikuhu al-afhām”?
- The existence of sound understanding
- Every possibility of knowing Allah
- The toil of creatures
- Complete comprehension of Allah’s essence by human understanding
Question 25
Which quality is illustrated by Yā Sīn 36:82 in these discussions?
- The independence of creatures
- Human sleep
- Allah’s will and complete power
- Allah’s need for sustenance
Question 26
The command “Kun” may include an appointed time for an event.
Question 27
Afhām means faulty thought while awhām means sound understanding.
Question 28
Allah requires created bodily organs in order to hear and see.
Question 29
The expression “Qayyūm” is accompanied by “lā yanām.”
Question 30
“Rāziqun bilā muʾnah” means creatures never encounter hardship in earning sustenance.
Question 31
Using the term “iḥyāʾ” for resurrection does not necessarily deny concealed life in the grave.
Open the interactive quiz