LessonsOrigination of Accidents and Substances: Premises, Objections and RepliesQuiz

Azal is not a particular earlier clock-time. It signifies absence of a temporal beginning. A particular originated event has a beginning, so calling that very event beginningless would contradict its characterization.

An opponent can nevertheless propose something different: each movement starts, yet the succession of different movements has no first member. No individual originated event is thereby called eternal; rather, the initial boundary of the series is in dispute.

Thus “one event is eternal” and “there is a beginningless succession of distinct events” must be analyzed as separate hypotheses.

Opening interactive controls...

Eternity versus one eternally existing event

Origination of Accidents and Substances: Premises, Objections and Replies

Azal is not a particular earlier clock-time. It signifies absence of a temporal beginning. A particular originated event has a beginning, so calling that very event beginningless would contradict its characterization.

An opponent can nevertheless propose something different: each movement starts, yet the succession of different movements has no first member. No individual originated event is thereby called eternal; rather, the initial boundary of the series is in dispute.

Thus “one event is eternal” and “there is a beginningless succession of distinct events” must be analyzed as separate hypotheses.