LessonsProof of Mutual Hindrance: Divine Unity, Conflicting Wills and Eternity of AttributesQuiz

A problem arises in classical kalām: if Allah’s essence is beginningless and His attributes are also beginningless, does that multiply independent necessary divine substances?

An essence concerns the independently existing being, whereas an attribute expresses a perfection such as knowledge, power, or life belonging to that being. To affirm an attribute as eternal is not to make it a separate, self-subsistent deity.

Calling divine knowledge eternal, for example, does not mean that knowledge is another god deliberating alongside Allah. Distinguishing the plurality of attributes from a plurality of independently necessary essences is essential to understanding unity together with the affirmation of divine perfections.

Opening interactive controls...

Why eternal attributes do not imply multiple gods

Proof of Mutual Hindrance: Divine Unity, Conflicting Wills and Eternity of Attributes

A problem arises in classical kalām: if Allah’s essence is beginningless and His attributes are also beginningless, does that multiply independent necessary divine substances?

An essence concerns the independently existing being, whereas an attribute expresses a perfection such as knowledge, power, or life belonging to that being. To affirm an attribute as eternal is not to make it a separate, self-subsistent deity.

Calling divine knowledge eternal, for example, does not mean that knowledge is another god deliberating alongside Allah. Distinguishing the plurality of attributes from a plurality of independently necessary essences is essential to understanding unity together with the affirmation of divine perfections.