LessonsThe Indivisible Atom: Arguments, Infinite Division and ObjectionsQuiz

وأشهرها عند المشايخ وجهان
Two arguments are especially prominent among the kalām scholars discussed here.

The first compares objects of very different magnitudes, illustrated by a mustard seed and a mountain. The second examines whether bodily parts can be joined or separated.

The first concerns magnitude and an allegedly infinite number of parts; the second relies on divine power, possibility and separation. Their premises and replies must be examined separately.

Opening interactive controls...

Two prominent demonstrations reported in kalām

The Indivisible Atom: Arguments, Infinite Division and Objections

وأشهرها عند المشايخ وجهان
Two arguments are especially prominent among the kalām scholars discussed here.

The first compares objects of very different magnitudes, illustrated by a mustard seed and a mountain. The second examines whether bodily parts can be joined or separated.

The first concerns magnitude and an allegedly infinite number of parts; the second relies on divine power, possibility and separation. Their premises and replies must be examined separately.