LessonsDialogue and Speech Acts — Questions, Promises, Challenges and ConfessionsQuiz

«إِنِّي مَا قَتَلْتُ ابْنَكَ سَهْوًا وَلَا عَمْدًا»
I did not kill your son, either inadvertently or intentionally.

Sahwan wa-lā ʿamdan denies two categories of alleged action: inadvertent and deliberate. The elder seeks a more exhaustive wording than a simple “I did not do it.”

Innī mā qataltu negates the past action, with the two adverbial terms clarifying the scope of the denial. The formula is still a demanded statement within a dispute. Its recitation alone does not establish the independent historical truth of the accusation.

Practice: Why name both manners? To exclude deliberate and inadvertent killing in the required denial.

Opening interactive controls...

A formula excluding both intent and accident

Dialogue and Speech Acts — Questions, Promises, Challenges and Confessions

«إِنِّي مَا قَتَلْتُ ابْنَكَ سَهْوًا وَلَا عَمْدًا»
I did not kill your son, either inadvertently or intentionally.

Sahwan wa-lā ʿamdan denies two categories of alleged action: inadvertent and deliberate. The elder seeks a more exhaustive wording than a simple “I did not do it.”

Innī mā qataltu negates the past action, with the two adverbial terms clarifying the scope of the denial. The formula is still a demanded statement within a dispute. Its recitation alone does not establish the independent historical truth of the accusation.

Practice: Why name both manners? To exclude deliberate and inadvertent killing in the required denial.