LessonsA Second Sense of Majāz: Case Changes Through Ellipsis and AdditionQuiz

وَيُحْتَمَلُ أَنْ لَا يَكُونَ زَائِدًا
It is also possible that the kāf is not additional.

On the alternative reading, kāf retains its normal comparative sense. The surface expression negates something “like His likeness,” but the intended meaning does not stop at that surface wording. Through indirect expression (kināyah), the wording is used to deny likeness to Him altogether.

Under this reading the syntactic construction genuinely includes kāf, while the emphasis of the meaning is understood through denying a consequence in order to deny what would entail it.

Opening interactive controls...

Alternative analysis: kāf need not be additional

A Second Sense of Majāz: Case Changes Through Ellipsis and Addition

وَيُحْتَمَلُ أَنْ لَا يَكُونَ زَائِدًا
It is also possible that the kāf is not additional.

On the alternative reading, kāf retains its normal comparative sense. The surface expression negates something “like His likeness,” but the intended meaning does not stop at that surface wording. Through indirect expression (kināyah), the wording is used to deny likeness to Him altogether.

Under this reading the syntactic construction genuinely includes kāf, while the emphasis of the meaning is understood through denying a consequence in order to deny what would entail it.