LessonsAl-Sakkaki on Derivative Metaphor, Implicit Metaphor, and the Role of Imaginative CluesQuiz

فلم تكن الاستعارة المكني عنها مستلزمة للتخييلية
Hence implicit metaphor would not necessarily entail imaginative metaphor.

This objection offers an analysis in which a concealed comparison can occur without establishing imagination in the narrower sense of attributing a hypothetical associated feature. It therefore challenges the universal proposition that every implicit metaphor must have an imaginative counterpart.

A defender can broaden the definition of imaginative attribution to include the action or relation in question. The claim, definition employed, and alleged counterexample must accordingly be examined separately.

Opening interactive controls...

Argument against making imaginative attribution compulsory

Al-Sakkaki on Derivative Metaphor, Implicit Metaphor, and the Role of Imaginative Clues

فلم تكن الاستعارة المكني عنها مستلزمة للتخييلية
Hence implicit metaphor would not necessarily entail imaginative metaphor.

This objection offers an analysis in which a concealed comparison can occur without establishing imagination in the narrower sense of attributing a hypothetical associated feature. It therefore challenges the universal proposition that every implicit metaphor must have an imaginative counterpart.

A defender can broaden the definition of imaginative attribution to include the action or relation in question. The claim, definition employed, and alleged counterexample must accordingly be examined separately.