LessonsAl-Sakkaki on Derivative Metaphor, Implicit Metaphor, and the Role of Imaginative CluesQuiz

In “the claws of death,” the clue can be described as a nonexistent bodily feature attributed to death. In “they break God’s covenant,” the clue is the action of breaking, which literally applies to material bonds and is figuratively used concerning a covenant.

The comparison raises a question: must every clue to implicit metaphor be the same kind of imagined attribute as the claws of death, or can a transferred action or relation serve as its clue?

The traditions answer this differently. Accordingly, one theory’s definition should not be imposed on a rival analysis without further argument.

Opening interactive controls...

Why is an imaginative feature disputed as a requirement?

Al-Sakkaki on Derivative Metaphor, Implicit Metaphor, and the Role of Imaginative Clues

In “the claws of death,” the clue can be described as a nonexistent bodily feature attributed to death. In “they break God’s covenant,” the clue is the action of breaking, which literally applies to material bonds and is figuratively used concerning a covenant.

The comparison raises a question: must every clue to implicit metaphor be the same kind of imagined attribute as the claws of death, or can a transferred action or relation serve as its clue?

The traditions answer this differently. Accordingly, one theory’s definition should not be imposed on a rival analysis without further argument.