LessonsIndications of Rational Metaphor and the Metaphor-by-Implication DebateQuiz

يَا هَامَانُ ابْنِ لِي صَرْحًا
O Hāmān, build for me a lofty structure. (Ghāfir 40:36)

Pharaoh commands Hāmān to build. The imperative addresses him, but does not necessarily require that he personally lift the bricks: the project may be executed through workers under his direction.

This illustrates the need to distinguish broad ordinary usage from specifically figurative attribution. If “build” conventionally extends to someone who commissions or manages building, then physical nonparticipation alone does not prove metaphor. Custom, authority and contextual evidence must be assessed.

Opening interactive controls...

Construction attributed to the person commanded

Indications of Rational Metaphor and the Metaphor-by-Implication Debate

يَا هَامَانُ ابْنِ لِي صَرْحًا
O Hāmān, build for me a lofty structure. (Ghāfir 40:36)

Pharaoh commands Hāmān to build. The imperative addresses him, but does not necessarily require that he personally lift the bricks: the project may be executed through workers under his direction.

This illustrates the need to distinguish broad ordinary usage from specifically figurative attribution. If “build” conventionally extends to someone who commissions or manages building, then physical nonparticipation alone does not prove metaphor. Custom, authority and contextual evidence must be assessed.