LessonsRefining the Jāmiʿ and the Conditions of Elegant CoordinationQuiz

The formula “unity in conception” may suggest a common conceived feature, while “unity in conceiving the two” may be misread as demanding that the complete meanings of both clauses coincide.

Total identity of two independent assertions would leave little room for an additional coordinated judgment. A more useful rhetorical test identifies the conceptual aspect shared by the clauses without treating their entire contents as synonymous.

Opening interactive controls...

Two readings of unity in conception

Refining the Jāmiʿ and the Conditions of Elegant Coordination

The formula “unity in conception” may suggest a common conceived feature, while “unity in conceiving the two” may be misread as demanding that the complete meanings of both clauses coincide.

Total identity of two independent assertions would leave little room for an additional coordinated judgment. A more useful rhetorical test identifies the conceptual aspect shared by the clauses without treating their entire contents as synonymous.