LessonsSupplementary Practice — Advanced Rhetorical Analysis and Worked TextsQuiz

“Kullu ṭ-ṭullābi lam yaḥḍurū” normally distributes the negation over all the students: none attended.

“Lam yaḥḍur kullu ṭ-ṭullāb” normally denies that every student attended; it allows that some did. The issue is universal negation versus negation of universality.

This is a difference in logical scope caused by word order. Particular contexts may sharpen the intended claim, but the two constructions do not have the same default force.

Opening interactive controls...

Negating all versus not affirming all

Supplementary Practice — Advanced Rhetorical Analysis and Worked Texts

“Kullu ṭ-ṭullābi lam yaḥḍurū” normally distributes the negation over all the students: none attended.

“Lam yaḥḍur kullu ṭ-ṭullāb” normally denies that every student attended; it allows that some did. The issue is universal negation versus negation of universality.

This is a difference in logical scope caused by word order. Particular contexts may sharpen the intended claim, but the two constructions do not have the same default force.