LessonsTafrīʿ, Praise or Blame by Apparent Exception, Ist itbāʿ and IdmājQuiz

Illā and siwā evoke exception, whereas lākin introduces a corrective or contrastive turn. In emphatic praise, these constructions can promise a qualification only to supply another excellence.

After “he is the moon,” saying “except that he is a sea” does not cancel the previous comparison. It shifts the image to a new dimension of praise; the following *lākin* does the same.

These connectors need not belong to a single grammatical category. What unites them here is the rhetorical reversal of expectation.

Opening interactive controls...

The rhetoric of illā, siwā and lākin

Tafrīʿ, Praise or Blame by Apparent Exception, Ist itbāʿ and Idmāj

Illā and siwā evoke exception, whereas lākin introduces a corrective or contrastive turn. In emphatic praise, these constructions can promise a qualification only to supply another excellence.

After “he is the moon,” saying “except that he is a sea” does not cancel the previous comparison. It shifts the image to a new dimension of praise; the following *lākin* does the same.

These connectors need not belong to a single grammatical category. What unites them here is the rhetorical reversal of expectation.