A passage can combine jinas with sajʿ or tasdir, but every claimed device must pass its own conditions. First test semantic contrast in the matching words, then determine whether they occupy sentence-final or opening positions.
Two occurrences of “ʿilm” with identical meanings are not jinas, even if the clauses rhyme. Similarly, sajʿ cannot prove tashriʿ, which requires alternative meaningful and metrically valid poetic endings.
Opening interactive controls...
Verbal Embellishments: Resembling Endings, Jinas, Sajʿ, and Further Devices
A passage can combine jinas with sajʿ or tasdir, but every claimed device must pass its own conditions. First test semantic contrast in the matching words, then determine whether they occupy sentence-final or opening positions.
Two occurrences of “ʿilm” with identical meanings are not jinas, even if the clauses rhyme. Similarly, sajʿ cannot prove tashriʿ, which requires alternative meaningful and metrically valid poetic endings.