This disagreement turns on the divisibility of a transaction. If one component of a unified agreement is invalid from the outset, can the valid component survive independently?
Abu Hanifah's ruling extends the defect through this particular composite sale. The disciples can preserve the fulus exchange because each part's consideration was expressly assigned.
These are rulings for the stated historical configuration, not an automatic formula governing every modern bundled transaction.
Opening interactive controls...
The reasoning behind indivisibility
Bab al-Sarf: Circulating Fulus, Obsolete Coins and Money-Changer Exchanges
This disagreement turns on the divisibility of a transaction. If one component of a unified agreement is invalid from the outset, can the valid component survive independently?
Abu Hanifah's ruling extends the defect through this particular composite sale. The disciples can preserve the fulus exchange because each part's consideration was expressly assigned.
These are rulings for the stated historical configuration, not an automatic formula governing every modern bundled transaction.