Fath al-Qadir also discusses making the two requests as genuinely separate exchanges. On a supported explanation, an independently valid fulus transaction need not fail simply because another separate silver exchange is impermissible.
Merely repeating words does not always create two valid contracts: the actual offer, acceptance, and whether one or two exchanges occurred matter. This is a commentary refinement, not an unrestricted rule read into Quduri's first formulation.
Opening interactive controls...
Separate requests versus one combined request
Bab al-Sarf: Circulating Fulus, Obsolete Coins and Money-Changer Exchanges
Fath al-Qadir also discusses making the two requests as genuinely separate exchanges. On a supported explanation, an independently valid fulus transaction need not fail simply because another separate silver exchange is impermissible.
Merely repeating words does not always create two valid contracts: the actual offer, acceptance, and whether one or two exchanges occurred matter. This is a commentary refinement, not an unrestricted rule read into Quduri's first formulation.