Fath al-Qadir distinguishes cutting an item from later disposing of it by sale. Cutting may still allow return with the seller’s consent; a later onward sale can change whether the buyer was effectively holding back an available remedy.
Cutting, sewing and reselling are therefore not interchangeable events.
The distinction is explanatory detail from the commentary, not wording inserted into Quduri’s original clause.
Opening interactive controls...
Khiyar al-Ayb: Defects, Remedies and Waiver
Fath al-Qadir distinguishes cutting an item from later disposing of it by sale. Cutting may still allow return with the seller’s consent; a later onward sale can change whether the buyer was effectively holding back an available remedy.
Cutting, sewing and reselling are therefore not interchangeable events.
The distinction is explanatory detail from the commentary, not wording inserted into Quduri’s original clause.