Muhammad al-Shaybani permits an independent sale if the bees are collected and capable of delivery, treating them as economically beneficial living things. The transmitted position of Abu Hanifa and Abu Yusuf limits the independent sale and allows bees as accessories to hives.
This is a reasoned disagreement within Hanafi law. Students must distinguish Quduri’s selected wording from the other transmitted position.
Opening interactive controls...
Muhammad al-Shaybani on independent bee sales
Kitab al-Buyu: Animal Sales, Silkworms, Bees and Dhimmi Transactions
Muhammad al-Shaybani permits an independent sale if the bees are collected and capable of delivery, treating them as economically beneficial living things. The transmitted position of Abu Hanifa and Abu Yusuf limits the independent sale and allows bees as accessories to hives.
This is a reasoned disagreement within Hanafi law. Students must distinguish Quduri’s selected wording from the other transmitted position.