Prophetic reports prohibit selling fruit before the signs of suitability. Yet Quduri permits selling existing fruit in certain pre-ripeness circumstances.
Hanafi jurists distinguish a present, identifiable crop whose removal follows sale from a transaction whose contractual arrangement leaves it on the seller's tree to ripen and exposes the parties to future risks.
This is a difference in interpreting the scope of the reports, not a dismissal of Prophetic evidence.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Buyu: Fruit Sales, Ripeness, Cutting and Reserved Quantities
Prophetic reports prohibit selling fruit before the signs of suitability. Yet Quduri permits selling existing fruit in certain pre-ripeness circumstances.
Hanafi jurists distinguish a present, identifiable crop whose removal follows sale from a transaction whose contractual arrangement leaves it on the seller's tree to ripen and exposes the parties to future risks.
This is a difference in interpreting the scope of the reports, not a dismissal of Prophetic evidence.