LessonsKitab al-Buyu: Offer, Acceptance, Binding Sales and Price ClarityQuiz

A present, specifically identified object differs from an undefined item to be supplied later.

Case 1: “This very vessel for 400.” The object is identified.
Case 2: “I will supply some vessel later.” Which material, grade, capacity and description? Uncertainty could defeat the contract.

Identification can remove ambiguity in a specific object; it is not a blanket permission for unknown goods.

Opening interactive controls...

A Specific Object Versus An Undefined Debt

Kitab al-Buyu: Offer, Acceptance, Binding Sales and Price Clarity

A present, specifically identified object differs from an undefined item to be supplied later.

Case 1: “This very vessel for 400.” The object is identified.
Case 2: “I will supply some vessel later.” Which material, grade, capacity and description? Uncertainty could defeat the contract.

Identification can remove ambiguity in a specific object; it is not a blanket permission for unknown goods.