The specified ruling addresses multiple assets pledged against one claim. It should not be casually extended to two independent security agreements for two separate debts.
Before deciding, identify whether there is one debt or two and whether the security was collectively pledged or separately constituted. Quduri’s clause concerns the first arrangement; the other must be assessed according to its own contracts and terms.
Opening interactive controls...
One secured contract versus separate security arrangements
Kitab al-Rahn: Partial Repayment, Agency to Sell and Pledgee Rights
The specified ruling addresses multiple assets pledged against one claim. It should not be casually extended to two independent security agreements for two separate debts.
Before deciding, identify whether there is one debt or two and whether the security was collectively pledged or separately constituted. Quduri’s clause concerns the first arrangement; the other must be assessed according to its own contracts and terms.