Imsāk is abstention for the remaining hours; an obligatory fast is a legally valid act spanning its prescribed time with its conditions. Abstaining only after midday does not retroactively create a full fast beginning at dawn.
Quduri therefore requires abstention but does not require this particular day to be made up. These are separate legal conclusions, not contradictory statements.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Sawm: Interrupted Voluntary Worship, Puberty and Conversion
Imsāk is abstention for the remaining hours; an obligatory fast is a legally valid act spanning its prescribed time with its conditions. Abstaining only after midday does not retroactively create a full fast beginning at dawn.
Quduri therefore requires abstention but does not require this particular day to be made up. These are separate legal conclusions, not contradictory statements.