Someone fears they ate after dawn, but reliable evidence shows they finished before dawn. The factual condition in Quduri’s mistake ruling is absent.
Likewise, if sunset had genuinely occurred before iftar, this particular source passage provides no basis to require make-up for early breaking.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Sawm: Mistaken Dawn or Sunset, Qada and Kaffarah
Someone fears they ate after dawn, but reliable evidence shows they finished before dawn. The factual condition in Quduri’s mistake ruling is absent.
Likewise, if sunset had genuinely occurred before iftar, this particular source passage provides no basis to require make-up for early breaking.