Suppose actual sunset is 6:20, but someone drinks water at 6:15 believing sunset has occurred. Later the reliable time is confirmed.
This is Quduri’s second mistaken-time scenario: the fast was broken early. Qaḍāʾ is required, while the special kaffarah is not due for that genuine error.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Sawm: Mistaken Dawn or Sunset, Qada and Kaffarah
Suppose actual sunset is 6:20, but someone drinks water at 6:15 believing sunset has occurred. Later the reliable time is confirmed.
This is Quduri’s second mistaken-time scenario: the fast was broken early. Qaḍāʾ is required, while the special kaffarah is not due for that genuine error.