Non-recitation arguments rely on listening, silence, and reports concerning the imam’s sufficiency. Recitation arguments rely on the general wording of the authentic Fatihah hadith. The core issue is which general text is specified by the other.
Opening interactive controls...
Comparing the Competing Proofs
Prayer Recitation: Surah Selection, Minimum Amount and Following the Imam
Non-recitation arguments rely on listening, silence, and reports concerning the imam’s sufficiency. Recitation arguments rely on the general wording of the authentic Fatihah hadith. The core issue is which general text is specified by the other.