LessonsKnowledge, Conception, Assent and Their DivisionsQuiz

The commentary describes two accounts of the nature of assent.

Philosophers: assent is the judgment, while the relevant conceptions are its necessary conditions.
Imam al-Razi: assent is analyzed as the composite of judgment and the conceptions of the terms.

In “Zayd is standing,” the subject, predicate, and connection must be understood. The disagreement concerns whether the total complex is called assent or the judgment alone is decisive.

The disagreement should be preserved, not erased; both accounts require grasping the concepts before making a meaningful judgment.

Opening interactive controls...

Philosophers and Imam al-Razi compared

Knowledge, Conception, Assent and Their Divisions

The commentary describes two accounts of the nature of assent.

Philosophers: assent is the judgment, while the relevant conceptions are its necessary conditions.
Imam al-Razi: assent is analyzed as the composite of judgment and the conceptions of the terms.

In “Zayd is standing,” the subject, predicate, and connection must be understood. The disagreement concerns whether the total complex is called assent or the judgment alone is decisive.

The disagreement should be preserved, not erased; both accounts require grasping the concepts before making a meaningful judgment.