«لا بالضرورة»
Not necessarily: the relation is not necessary in virtue of the subject itself.
This is not the same as declaring the first judgment false. A particular person may actually be writing, but writing is not essential to that person's existence; the person can remain human without writing.
Bi-l-fiʿl concerns actuality, whereas lā bi-l-ḍarūrah denies essential necessity. What happens and what must happen are logically distinct.
Opening interactive controls...
The Seven Compound Modalities and the Negations of Permanence and Necessity
«لا بالضرورة»
Not necessarily: the relation is not necessary in virtue of the subject itself.
This is not the same as declaring the first judgment false. A particular person may actually be writing, but writing is not essential to that person's existence; the person can remain human without writing.
Bi-l-fiʿl concerns actuality, whereas lā bi-l-ḍarūrah denies essential necessity. What happens and what must happen are logically distinct.