LessonsAuthority, Ranks and Composite Forms of IjmaQuiz

ومثاله: الإجماع على وجود الانتقاض عند القيء، ومس المرأة.
An example concerns the loss of ablution in a combined case of vomiting and touching a woman.

One person both vomits and experiences the relevant physical contact. The Hanafi position treats qualifying vomiting as nullifying ablution; the Shafi'i position treats qualifying contact as nullifying it. Both may therefore conclude that ablution has been lost in the combined scenario.

Common result: renewed ablution is required.
First jurist’s reason: vomiting.
Second jurist’s reason: contact.

Agreement on the result is not agreement on the cause.

Opening interactive controls...

A worked example: vomiting and contact

Authority, Ranks and Composite Forms of Ijma

ومثاله: الإجماع على وجود الانتقاض عند القيء، ومس المرأة.
An example concerns the loss of ablution in a combined case of vomiting and touching a woman.

One person both vomits and experiences the relevant physical contact. The Hanafi position treats qualifying vomiting as nullifying ablution; the Shafi'i position treats qualifying contact as nullifying it. Both may therefore conclude that ablution has been lost in the combined scenario.

Common result: renewed ablution is required.
First jurist’s reason: vomiting.
Second jurist’s reason: contact.

Agreement on the result is not agreement on the cause.