LessonsDivine Transcendence: Form, Essence, Place and TimeQuiz

Ḥayyiz (spatial region or occupation) and makān (place) are closely related but not always equivalent technical terms. Some theologians use ḥayyiz for the putative region occupied by a body, whether or not it is enclosed by another object.

Other definitions of makān stress the containing surface or the particular relation of a body to a surrounding body. Under such definitions, a scholar might speak of spatial occupation yet deny place in a narrower technical sense.

A sound argument must first identify which meaning of “region” and “place” is being used instead of treating every occurrence as interchangeable.

Opening interactive controls...

Ḥayyiz and makān are not always synonymous

Divine Transcendence: Form, Essence, Place and Time

Ḥayyiz (spatial region or occupation) and makān (place) are closely related but not always equivalent technical terms. Some theologians use ḥayyiz for the putative region occupied by a body, whether or not it is enclosed by another object.

Other definitions of makān stress the containing surface or the particular relation of a body to a surrounding body. Under such definitions, a scholar might speak of spatial occupation yet deny place in a narrower technical sense.

A sound argument must first identify which meaning of “region” and “place” is being used instead of treating every occurrence as interchangeable.