OutcomeEvidenceAssessment
Later is betterImprovement in composition, concision, clarity or thoughtPraised
Later is equalNo clear additional excellenceNo distinctive praise
Later is worseA virtue of the earlier is lostCriticized
The critic first identifies the nature of the taking and then evaluates the resulting expression. Neither poetic reputation nor chronology alone determines the relative degree of eloquence.
Opening interactive controls...
Ighārah and Maskh: Recasting Verse, Eloquence and Literary Appraisal
OutcomeEvidenceAssessment
Later is betterImprovement in composition, concision, clarity or thoughtPraised
Later is equalNo clear additional excellenceNo distinctive praise
Later is worseA virtue of the earlier is lostCriticized
The critic first identifies the nature of the taking and then evaluates the resulting expression. Neither poetic reputation nor chronology alone determines the relative degree of eloquence.