LessonsSupplementary Integrated Rhetoric Workshop: Text Analysis, Stylistic Revision and Worked ApplicationsQuiz

كَأَنَّ مُثَارَ النَّقْعِ فَوْقَ رُؤُوسِنَا وَأَسْيَافَنَا لَيْلٌ تَهَاوَى كَوَاكِبُهُ
The stirred dust above our heads and our swords seem like a night whose stars are falling.

Calling only the swords “stars” loses the larger setting. The dust forms a dark field while flashing swords move within it like falling stars; the common aspect lies in an integrated arrangement.

A complete answer may identify local correspondences but should conclude by reconstructing the composite image. The artistic comparison concerns an overall scene rather than a single isolated noun.

Opening interactive controls...

Case 6: Single resemblance or composite scene?

Supplementary Integrated Rhetoric Workshop: Text Analysis, Stylistic Revision and Worked Applications

كَأَنَّ مُثَارَ النَّقْعِ فَوْقَ رُؤُوسِنَا وَأَسْيَافَنَا لَيْلٌ تَهَاوَى كَوَاكِبُهُ
The stirred dust above our heads and our swords seem like a night whose stars are falling.

Calling only the swords “stars” loses the larger setting. The dust forms a dark field while flashing swords move within it like falling stars; the common aspect lies in an integrated arrangement.

A complete answer may identify local correspondences but should conclude by reconstructing the composite image. The artistic comparison concerns an overall scene rather than a single isolated noun.