LessonsTafrīʿ, Praise or Blame by Apparent Exception, Ist itbāʿ and IdmājQuiz

Ordinary exception is analyzed as connected or disconnected according to context and construction. Here, however, the rhetorical question is how the expectation of a defect has been established and then overturned.

An imagined connected exception can evoke inclusion among faults; a disconnected reading brings out the different semantic category. These grammatical analyses should be distinguished from the intended rhetorical reinforcement.

The figure arises when exception-like wording adds force to praise instead of merely reporting an exclusion.

Opening interactive controls...

Ordinary exception and rhetorical confirmation

Tafrīʿ, Praise or Blame by Apparent Exception, Ist itbāʿ and Idmāj

Ordinary exception is analyzed as connected or disconnected according to context and construction. Here, however, the rhetorical question is how the expectation of a defect has been established and then overturned.

An imagined connected exception can evoke inclusion among faults; a disconnected reading brings out the different semantic category. These grammatical analyses should be distinguished from the intended rhetorical reinforcement.

The figure arises when exception-like wording adds force to praise instead of merely reporting an exclusion.