LessonsThe Second Figure: Conditions of Validity and Four Productive MoodsQuiz

The commentary uses reductio ad absurdum (khalf). Assume both premises true and the intended conclusion false. If this forces the contradiction of a premise, the assumed falsity of the conclusion must be rejected.

Example:
All cats are animals.
No stone is an animal.
Target: No cat is a stone.

If that target were false, some cats would be stones. Those cats would be animals by the minor and non-animals by the major—an outright contradiction. Thus the negative conclusion follows.

Opening interactive controls...

Why reductio can prove validity

The Second Figure: Conditions of Validity and Four Productive Moods

The commentary uses reductio ad absurdum (khalf). Assume both premises true and the intended conclusion false. If this forces the contradiction of a premise, the assumed falsity of the conclusion must be rejected.

Example:
All cats are animals.
No stone is an animal.
Target: No cat is a stone.

If that target were false, some cats would be stones. Those cats would be animals by the minor and non-animals by the major—an outright contradiction. Thus the negative conclusion follows.