Quduri's main text prohibits reserving specified ratls from unseparated fruit. Commentators nevertheless discuss the supporting reasoning, variant transmissions and alternative juristic analyses.
Fath al-Qadir records discussion of a report through al-Hasan, al-Tahawi's position and possible derivation from zahir al-riwayah.
For learning the Quduri text, retain its clear stated rule; for scholarly accuracy, do not hide that commentarial discussion exists.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Buyu: Fruit Sales, Ripeness, Cutting and Reserved Quantities
Quduri's main text prohibits reserving specified ratls from unseparated fruit. Commentators nevertheless discuss the supporting reasoning, variant transmissions and alternative juristic analyses.
Fath al-Qadir records discussion of a report through al-Hasan, al-Tahawi's position and possible derivation from zahir al-riwayah.
For learning the Quduri text, retain its clear stated rule; for scholarly accuracy, do not hide that commentarial discussion exists.